Given the choice, I would rather spend my days out of doors than cooped up inside, even though at this time of year the elements start to conspire against me. Still, I feel an overwhelming need to get outside into the fresh air and stretch my legs whatever the weather and if there is no serious gardening to be done, then walking is my favourite option. In the light of some very autumnal weather ~ goodness me, it is so wet here at the moment! ~ this week has seen me digging out my waterproof over-trousers, coat and walking boots for the first time in many months. I am lucky to have a choice of ways to wander from home but it doesn’t bother me if I end up walking the same stretch several times a week; there is something wonderful in simply being outside and moving, breathing in the fresh, autumnal air and noting the subtle changes in field, tree and hedgerow that mark our passage through this beautiful season. Not so delightful is the litter I’ve been picking up along the way this week. To be fair, it’s an unusual thing in these parts but too many days have seen me returning home with someone else’s beer can, cigarette packet, energy drink sachet and sweet wrappers to dispose of responsibly; it’s a grotty job but I have far too much respect for nature to leave it there. The word litter originally referred to animal bedding such as straw which has me thinking that if only what I’ve been picking up were biodegradable in the same way, there would be no issue . . . and that has led me circling back, at long last, to a post I’ve had sitting patiently in draft form for ages. Let’s talk about waste.
Tackling the gargantuan issue of waste is a complicated and often thorny issue but one that is both essential and pressing. At an individual level, it can seem like an overwhelming task so I think it’s important to listen to voices like Anne-Marie Bonneau (‘The Zero Waste Chef’) and Patrick Whitefield who advise against trying to do everything perfectly but doing what we can and concentrating on those things that are most relevant. I’ve been thinking about waste again this week in light of ~ amongst other things ~ another reading of the French 2020 Anti-waste Law (English version here). France doesn’t have a great track record when it comes to the matter of waste but this charter sets out ambitious plans and targets, not just for reducing waste but also for a system-wide transition from a linear economy to a circular one and I think it’s refreshing and encouraging to see a Western government setting out its stall in this way. There are a couple of world firsts in there, too, namely the ban on the destruction of unsold food products and a mandatory repairability index for electrical and electronic products in a start to banish planned obsolescence; the emphasis is also on using the changes to bring about ‘societal transformation’ and supporting the more vulnerable members of society through the adoption of a circular economy. It’s enterprising and, to a degree, pioneering stuff and given that many of the measures have been in place for some time now, makes an interesting template for my personal reflections.
Comparing the details in the Anti-waste Law document with what I can see going on (or not) has led to some interesting observations:
Some measures have obviously been put in place so for instance, plastic shopping bags are very much a thing of the past. People seem to have adapted to taking their own reusable bags to shops and on the rare occasion a shop attendant has put our purchases in a bag (for instance, at the local country store), the bag has been a sturdy paper one for which I can find many uses. In order to save paper and ink waste, customers now have the choice as to whether to have a till receipt or not and we are always asked. I’m very happy not to have one although it can cause issues if items need to be returned. A few months ago, I bought some loose prawns from the fishmonger’s counter in a local supermarket only to find once I’d left the premises, that they had been priced as scallops (over five times the price!); when I returned to the customer service desk for a refund, the first thing I was asked for was my till receipt. Mmm.
Other measures exist but don’t appear to be much used: as mentioned in a previous post, since 2021, French customers have been able to take their own containers to buy loose goods as long as they are clean and fit for purpose but the only person I’ve ever seen do that is me. I’m not sure whether it’s down to a lack of awareness of the possibility being there or a disinclination to do it but it would be encouraging to see it become a regular and more widespread habit. Certainly, not a single shop assistant has batted an eyebrow at my taking my own containers so as a customer, there is no awkwardness or problem at all. On my last visit to the local organic dairy where milk, yogurt and cheese are all bought in our own bottles, bags and pots, I noticed a large sticker on the counter with the title (weirdly, in English) of ‘Bring your own containers!’ It would be good to see such encouragement everywhere.
Some measures appear to be non-existent: there are supposed to be receptacles at checkouts so that customers can deposit unnecessary packaging as a message for producers but I’ve yet to see evidence of such bins in any supermarket, big or small.
There are encouraging signs of gradual change, however, and I remain hopeful that the impetus will grow and it will start to filter into everyday life more quickly. Our local garage is displaying posters explaining how they can be part of a circular economy and all the possibilities open to them in terms of re-using, repairing and recycling vehicle parts rather than always opting for new. It is now prohibited to throw old toys and sports equipment away at our local déchetterie, they are instead sorted and collected with an eye on extending their lives. There are businesses and schemes across France focusing on activities such as collecting and re-using glass bottles, repairing old bikes and distributing them to those without and mending or upcycling old clothes. Next year, Paris hosts the Olympic Games and amongst many innovative ‘green schemes’ already being implemented in the city (such as rooftop farms and cleaning the River Seine for safe swimming), the organisers have set themselves an ambitious target of halving the carbon footprint of previous Games. I’m interested to see how that goes but it surely needs to be a priority in any ‘world’ event now.
Food waste is an area where we personally don’t do too badly because we never really have any. I think this comes down to several strategies: we only ever buy what we need, we plan all our meals around what we’ve got and prioritise the use of anything that is creeping past its best, where we buy in bulk we ensure foods are properly stored or preserved, any leftovers are revamped into another meal or frozen for another day, we only put on our plate what we can eat, we cook everything from scratch so we can tailor dishes and meals to our own tastes and any peelings, eggshells, coffee grounds and other biodegradable bits and pieces are composted (although in many cases we adopt a ‘skins-on’ approach and eat the peel anyway).
I agree with Anne-Marie Bonneau that composting food should be a last resort; I was very grieved over winter when some of our stored squash started to rot and despite saving what we could, the rest ended up on the compost heap. This year, I’ve raised fewer plants but also prioritised varieties which I know are good keepers to avoid that kind of scenario again; the fact that we’ve ended up with a huge harvest isn’t helpful but I will give as many squash away as I can. Growing the vast bulk of our fruit and vegetables means a healthy diet, a reduced carbon footprint and a huge sense of respect for food, knowing that any waste doesn’t just mean the foodstuff itself but the water, energy and other inputs that have contributed to its production. From 1st January 2024, all French homes must have by law the facility to recycle food waste so local councils are currently making domestic collection buckets and compost bins available to all households . . . not that we need either.
If we are going to really tackle the issue of waste, then I believe the approach needs to be holistic and all-encompassing. Take teabags as an example. Since 1st January 2022, the use of plastic in teabags has been prohibited in France and this is a good thing because the amount of microplastic particles released from teabags at brewing temperature is a huge environmental issue; plastic-free teabags can also be safely composted so become something useful rather than a part of the waste stream. However . . . teabags in France usually come with a string and cardboard tab, sometimes attached with a metal staple (not compostable) and are often individually wrapped in plastic inside a glossy cardboard box which itself has an outer plastic wrapper. That’s an awful lot of waste packaging for 20 cups of tea! Somehow I doubt that anyone would have the time or inclination to remove all those wrappers even if the collection bins were available at the checkout. Tea is one of the few things I bring back to France after a visit to the UK (and thankfully, it remains a legal import post-Brexit) but the only bag involved is a sturdy brown one which I re-use many times. I buy a good quality loose-leaf Assam tea which is weighed into the paper bag and which I then decant into my faithful old tea ‘caddy’, a heavy jar made from recycled glass with a cork top that I’ve had for nearly 30 years. It’s a luxury ~ a few hundred grams have to last me many months ~ so my other tea moments involve gathering herbs from the garden. I’m an unapologetic tea snob so always use a teapot which means I have no need (or desire) for teabags anyway; I think there’s a rather lovely meditative process to warming the pot, adding leaves, pouring over boiling water, leaving to brew and then sitting back and savouring. Plus as tea leaves and spent herbs are excellent compost ingredients, there’s no waste. Perhaps teapots should be issued alongside compost bins? 😉
Along similar lines, if I go to the local boulangerie to buy croissants or pain au chocolat for a breakfast treat, they will be wrapped in a brown paper bag whereas in supermarkets they are often sold in large rigid lidded plastic boxes which I think are a clear example of unnecessary plastics. They do make good mini-cloches for seedlings but my guess is the vast majority end up being thrown away. Many people will buy breakfast pastries from supermarkets as they are convenient, have good in-store bakeries and you generally get far more for your money but I’ve felt for a long time that the boxes surely need to go or else some sort of returnable scheme be put in place as is due to happen with plastic bottles in France at some point this year. The good news this week is that we saw croissants for sale in paper bags in a local supermarket for the first time, although the special offers were still in plastic boxes; it’s a welcome step in the right direction, at least. Cultural shifts take time and effort but I have a hunch that if customers had to serve themselves into paper bags (or even better, their own reusable bags) then the croissants would still fly off the shelves. Only time will tell.
The way in which our household waste is managed is set to change very soon following pilot schemes in several local communes and having this week seen a general household waste bin stuffed to the gunwales with cardboard and electronic equipment, including a computer keyboard, I think this can only be a good thing. Under the present scheme, we pay an annual fee for the management of our waste, both rubbish and recycling. We have no kerbside collection so we have to take everything to one of the many communal collection points; the nearest is a couple of kilometres away and has a general rubbish bin and recycling bins for glass, paper, metal, some plastics and clothing. Under the new scheme, an annual charge will remain but the general household bins will be locked with access only by using a microchipped ‘badge’: this will record the number of times we open the bin to deposit a maximum of 60 litres of rubbish at a time and beyond a minimum allowance (yet to be announced), an additional charge will be added to our bill accordingly.
We’ve lived with this system before in another commune of Mayenne and in theory it should encourage people to think more about recycling what they can and reducing their waste in general; one of the biggest problems here is that many people don’t sort their rubbish and just throw everything away. However, it’s not without problems, fly tipping being a major one as people furtively dump rubbish bags in a pile next to the collection bins to avoid charges or else burn it if they have no close neighbours. Also, I think it would be a fairer system to base the charges on the weight of rubbish deposited rather than the number of deposits: our household rubbish amounts to so little that we collect it in old freezer bags which are beyond re-use and weigh in at 100 grams or below every few weeks. The point is, every time we open the bin we will be charged the same as someone who has deposited 60 litres of rubbish (we couldn’t produce that in a year!) so it will mean us having to store up our bits of rubbish for longer which is not the healthiest of situations and hardly encourages people to move towards a zero waste lifestyle. I know I’m not the only person who has raised this point but the local council argues that a weighing system would be hugely expensive to install and so bills would have to be much higher. Well, no system is perfect, I suppose. It remains to be seen what will happen when the new scheme starts in this commune (2024 is a trial year, we have collected our badge this week) but I’m hoping that within the ethos of the Anti-waste Law, there will be an acceptance that a low waste lifestyle ~ without fly tipping ~ is not only possible, but to be encouraged.
Ecological sobriety is something I’ve been reading about in several journalistic articles this week; for anglophones, the word ‘sobriety’ tends to allude to temperance but in this (French) use, it means ‘simplicity’ and refers to people choosing a simpler lifestyle in order to help the planet. It seems there is a groundswell of movement in France away from negatively equating such simplicity with austerity but instead seeing it as a beneficial and positive move. More and more people, especially among the younger generations, are finding that by swapping stressful jobs for something more pleasant, and reducing many things in their life including the size of property and amount of travel (especially flights), along with consumption of everything from food to social media, they are feeling much happier. For some, it’s a case of doing what they can, even if the gestures seem small, for others it’s a complete shift in lifestyle to off-grid, communal living. What I like most about what I’ve read is the emphasis on reducing because for me, this is a key word: if everyone reduced their consumption by just a small amount ~ whether energy, water, clothes, stuff, travel, food ~ and at the same time, focused on reducing the associated waste, the impact would be massive. No-one is talking about doing without but it seems many people would be much happier, too, so surely as a society this is what we ought to be aiming for, the well-being of people and the planet.
As a personal example, last year I bought a pack of yarn to crochet a blanket as a gift for Sam and Adrienne. I normally knit them woolly socks to take as host and hostess gifts when we stay but as I knew we were driving to Norway (or at least, that was the plan before things went pear-shaped in Germany!), I decided to make a blanket instead, something bright and colourful which I hoped would help to lift the gloom of winter days in Stavanger. I chose the ‘Aria’ design from Attic 24 and it proved to be an interesting project; there were very few squares where I would have chosen the same colour combinations but when it was put together, it was incredibly effective . . . which is why Lucy designs blankets and I grow squash. 😂
The blanket packs are all pretty generous so I was left with quite a pile of spare yarn and decided to use some of the greens, blues and purples to knit a quirky little jacket for our youngest grandchild, just pulling random balls out of my basket to make uneven stripes. I love this kind of relaxed project, simply making it up as I go along and, once finished, somehow the idea of mismatched buttons seemed to suit the mood.
Believe it or not, I still have yarn left over so my plan is to gift it, along with other bits and pieces, to those who knit toys and the like for charity and as I used the packaging for other things, I’m hoping this means there will be minimal waste from my original purchase. Yes, of course, I acted as a consumer in buying the yarn which came with its own carbon footprint but it gave me the materials I needed to create personal and meaningful gifts made with time, effort, much pleasure and a lot of love. It’s so easy to beat ourselves up about these things but I firmly believe that if we can just stand back and reflect quietly and holistically on the entire life span of everything we buy, use or consume, and make a conscious effort to keep as much as possible out of the waste stream for as long as possible, then the difference would be enormous. Walking lightly on the Earth doesn’t need to be painful, sacrificial or even difficult, it just needs a small shift in perspective . . . and perhaps a bit of voluntary litter picking on the side. 😊